Most households and organisations run on a simple theory of motivation: reward the behaviour you want and penalise the behaviour you do not. Stars for homework. Bonuses for targets. Lost privileges for bad behaviour.

This approach works in some situations. In others, it produces less than we expect, and sometimes the opposite. Understanding why requires a distinction psychologists have studied for more than fifty years: the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation.

Two kinds of motivation

Intrinsic motivation is the drive to do something because it is interesting, enjoyable or meaningful in itself. A child who reads late into the night because she loves the story is intrinsically motivated. So is an engineer who stays on a problem because he wants to solve it.

Extrinsic motivation is the drive to do something for a separate outcome: a reward, praise, a grade, avoiding punishment. A child who reads to earn screen time is extrinsically motivated. So is an employee who completes training only because it is linked to a bonus.

Most real behaviour involves both. The question for parents and leaders is how the two interact.

When rewards backfire

In 1973, Mark Lepper, David Greene and Richard Nisbett studied preschool children who already enjoyed drawing. One group was told that if they drew, they would receive a Good Player certificate. Another group drew without expecting any reward. Some children received an unexpected certificate afterwards.

Two weeks later, observed during free play, the children who had drawn for the expected certificate spent about half as much time drawing as the other groups. Their interest had dropped. The children who received an unexpected reward showed no such drop.

The researchers called this the overjustification effect. When people receive an expected reward for something they already enjoy, they may begin to see the activity as a means to an end, and their natural interest declines.

In 1999, Edward Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard Ryan reviewed 128 experiments and found that expected tangible rewards reliably reduced intrinsic motivation for interesting tasks, especially among children. They also found that sincere positive feedback tended to increase it.

What people need

Deci and Ryan’s self determination theory proposes that intrinsic motivation grows when three needs are met: autonomy, competence and relatedness. People thrive when they have some choice, when they are growing in skill and when they feel connected to others.

This explains why controlling rewards can backfire. A reward offered as “do this and you will get that” can feel like control, reducing autonomy. Feedback that says “you handled that well, here is what made it work” supports competence and relatedness instead.

The power of progress and acknowledgement

Teresa Amabile and Steven Kramer’s analysis of nearly 12,000 diary entries from professionals found that making progress in meaningful work was the most powerful influence on a good working day. Yet when 669 managers were asked to rank motivators, they ranked progress last.

Dan Ariely, Emir Kamenica and Drazen Prelec showed how fragile motivation can be. In one experiment, participants completed simple tasks on sheets of paper for decreasing payments. When the experimenter acknowledged each sheet with a glance and a nod, people kept working much longer. When he ignored the sheets, people stopped almost as quickly as when he shredded them in front of them.

Together, these studies suggest that people need to see that their work goes somewhere and that someone notices.

What this means at home

A mother in Port Harcourt described to me how she paid her son for every book he finished. At first he read eagerly. Within months he was choosing the shortest books he could find and asking whether comics counted. When she stopped paying and started asking him to tell her about the stories over dinner, his reading slowly recovered.

For parents, a few principles follow:

Avoid paying children for activities they already enjoy, such as reading, drawing or sport.

Use rewards sparingly for tasks that genuinely are not enjoyable, and consider unexpected rather than promised rewards.

Recognise effort and progress specifically.

Give children real choices within limits.

Show interest in what they are doing, not only in the result.

What this means at work

At work, fair pay is the foundation. Without it, little else matters. Beyond fair pay, the research suggests:

Make progress visible, especially in long projects.

Recognise specific effort and contribution rather than relying on generic award schemes.

Give people as much choice as the work allows over how they do it.

Acknowledge work promptly. Silence is rarely neutral.

Be cautious about incentive schemes for complex or creative work, where rewards can narrow focus.

A Lagos fintech I learnt about replaced its monthly sales leaderboard, which had created rivalry and corner cutting, with a weekly session where team members described one client problem they had solved and how. Sales did not fall. Collaboration rose.

The workshop

This month I am running a workshop on intrinsic and extrinsic motivation for parents, leaders and team members. We will look at what drives people, how to recognise effort well and how to design rewards that support rather than replace inner motivation. Details are at www.deleagbogun.com.