Every parent wants their child to feel confident. Every manager wants their team to believe in their own abilities. So it seems natural to tell a child “you are so clever” or a new employee “you are a natural at this”.
Research over the past three decades suggests that this kind of praise, however well meant, can have unintended effects. The way we praise shapes how people respond to difficulty, and in the long run, whether they keep growing.
The puzzle experiments
In 1998, Claudia Mueller and Carol Dweck published a series of six studies involving more than 400 children aged around ten and eleven. In a typical study, each child completed a set of moderately difficult puzzles. Every child was then told they had done well. One group was praised for intelligence: “You must be smart at these problems.” Another was praised for effort: “You must have worked hard at these problems.” A control group received praise for the outcome alone.
The children were then offered a choice of next task. Most of those praised for intelligence chose an easier task that would let them look clever. Most of those praised for effort chose a more challenging task that would let them learn.
Next, every child received a set of much harder puzzles on which they performed poorly. Children praised for intelligence enjoyed the puzzles less, persisted less and were more likely to attribute their failure to a lack of ability. On a final set of moderate puzzles, their performance dropped. Children praised for effort performed better than before.
When the children were later asked to write about the puzzles for children at another school, including their scores, nearly four in ten of those praised for intelligence exaggerated their results. Among children praised for effort, the proportion was much lower.
Why intelligence praise backfires
Dweck’s explanation is that praise for intelligence teaches a fixed view of ability. If you are praised for being clever, then struggling suggests you might not be clever after all. Avoiding difficulty protects that identity. Exaggerating results protects it further.
Praise for effort teaches a different lesson. It suggests that ability grows through work, strategy and persistence. Struggling then becomes part of learning rather than evidence of inadequacy. Dweck later described these two patterns as the fixed and growth mindsets.
It is worth noting that the mindset research has been debated, and some large studies have found smaller effects than early work suggested. The core finding about praise, however, has held up well. How we praise affects how people approach challenge.
It starts early
In 2013, Elizabeth Gunderson and colleagues recorded parents interacting with their children at home when the children were between one and three years old. They counted different types of praise. Some was praise for the person (“good girl”, “you are so smart”). Some was process praise, focused on effort, strategy or actions (“you worked hard on that”, “good throwing”).
Five years later, when the children were seven and eight, the researchers measured their beliefs about ability. Children whose parents had used more process praise in the toddler years were more likely to believe that ability could be developed through effort, and to prefer challenging tasks.
The words we use with very young children appear to shape how they understand effort years later.
What effort praise sounds like
Praising effort does not mean praising every attempt regardless of quality, or telling children who did not try that they worked hard. Dweck has warned against empty effort praise that rewards trying without learning. Good process praise is specific and honest. It names what the person actually did.
For children:
“You tried three different ways to solve that before it worked.”
“You kept practising that piece even when it sounded wrong. Listen to it now.”
“You were kind to your sister when she was upset, even though you were tired.”
For colleagues and team members:
“You rewrote that proposal after the client’s feedback rather than defending the first version. That made the difference.”
“You asked for help early on the audit. That saved the whole team a week.”
“You stayed calm with that customer when she was shouting. That takes discipline.”
When the result is poor
Effort praise is most valuable when results disappoint. A child in Kano who studied hard for an examination and still received a low mark needs to hear something different from “never mind, you are clever”. A more helpful response acknowledges the effort, then looks honestly at the strategy: “I saw how much you studied. Let us look at which topics went well and which did not, and think about what to try differently next time.”
A team in a Glasgow engineering firm I learnt about began holding short reviews after unsuccessful bids, opening with recognition of the work that went into each one before discussing what to change. The team leader told me the reviews became the most useful meeting in their calendar, because people no longer arrived defensive.
Start with one sentence a day
Choose one person each day this week, a child, a spouse or a colleague, and praise one specific effort, strategy or act of persistence. Avoid labels such as clever, talented or natural. Notice what changes in how they approach the next challenge.
If you would like to go further, my workshop on intrinsic and extrinsic motivation this month explores how recognition shapes motivation at home and at work. Details are at www.deleagbogun.com.